2.3: Acid-catalyzed SN1 reaction

  • Adding an acid catalyst increases the rate of SN1 reactions with poor leaving groups such as HO- or RO-.
  • The acid-catalyzed SN1 mechanism involves four key steps: (1) an initial acid/base step to improve the leaving group, (2)/(3) the standard steps of an SN1 mechanism, and (4) a final acid/base step to give the neutral product.

The rate determining step of an SN1 reaction requires the leaving group to leave. If the electrophile is covalently bonded to a poor leaving group, such as HO- or RO-, this step can be so slow that the reaction does not proceed at all.

5-2-3-sn1-with-poor-lg

In these cases, adding an acid catalyst can protonate the leaving group before it leaves, turning it into a much better leaving group such as H2O or ROH. This significantly increases the rate of the reaction.  For example, consider the substitution reaction between 2-methylpropanol and methanol, shown below. The leaving group, HO- is poor, so an acid catalyst, such as CH3OH2+, is necessary to enable the reaction.

5-2-3-acid-cat-sn1-overall-rxn

In the mechanism of this reaction, the first step is an acid-base reaction where the acid catalyst protonates the alcohol to make it a better leaving group. Steps 2 and 3 are the standard steps of an SN1 mechanism: the leaving group leaves, and then the nucleophile attacks the carbocation intermediate. The result is the protonated substituted product, similar to what was shown in Section 2.2 when neutral nucleophiles were used.  The fourth and final step is another acid/base reaction to deprotonate this molecule. In many SN1 reactions, the nucleophile is used as the solvent. This makes the nucleophile/solvent a good choice to use as a base for the final deprotonation, since (1) it has two electrons available to act as a base (recall that nucleophiles have lone pair electrons) and (2) they are available in excess (since it is the solvent). Note that this final step reproduces the acid, making it catalytic.

5-2-3-acid-cat-sn1-mech

Guided:
Note: the interactive components of this tutorial require html5 video, which is not supported by some mobile devices (e.g. iPhones). This tutorial is best viewed on a computer.

 

Interactive:

The mechanism for an acid-catalyzed SN1 reaction is shown below, but one of the blue mechanistic arrows is incorrect. Select the incorrect mechanistic arrow.
Drag and drop the molecules in the grey box to correctly complete the mechanism below.